Big Cartel vs Shopify: Which Platform Takes The Lead For E-commerce?

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Big Cartel vs Shopify: Comparing Two E-commerce Titans
  3. FAQ Section
  4. Conclusion

Introduction

When it comes to choosing a platform for setting up an e-commerce storefront, both Big Cartel and Shopify present themselves as capable options. However, they cater to different types of sellers and offer varied levels of customization and features. This post will provide an in-depth analysis, aiming to guide you through understanding which platform suits your business best.

Big Cartel vs Shopify: Comparing Two E-commerce Titans

Ease of Use and User Experience

Starting an online store can be daunting, but both Big Cartel and Shopify simplify the process. Big Cartel markets itself as the go-to platform for artists and makers. It requires no coding skills, thanks to its intuitive interface and pre-set free themes, making it quick and easy to set up a store. On the flip side, Shopify offers a more powerful and sophisticated experience. With its drag-drop interface and high level of customization, Shopify is user-friendly but may have a steeper learning curve for some users.

Pricing and Fees

When we talk about affordability, Big Cartel may initially come out on top because of its free plan. However, its range of features may feel limited for growing businesses. In contrast, Shopify's plans, starting with a free trial, might seem pricey but offer more value due to their extensive feature lists and scalability. Additionally, Shopify's transaction fees are something to consider if not using their payment gateway.

Scalability and Flexibility

Scalability might be a concern if you opt for Big Cartel due to its product limits, whereas Shopify shows muscle in this domain. Shopify supports unlimited products and boasts a mighty arsenal of tools to scale your business.

Themes and Designs

Design-wise, Big Cartel’s themes are simple and appealing but leave little room for customization without coding knowledge. Shopify's themes are not only numerous but also provide greater control over store designs, even allowing users to switch themes without repercussion, contributing greatly to a store's branding flexibility.

Features and Functionalities

Big Cartel keeps it basic with features that cover the essentials for small shop owners. Contrastingly, Shopify is feature-rich, supporting numerous sales channels, providing comprehensive inventory management, blogging capabilities, and more. Shopify's app store, with thousands of integrations, outperforms Big Cartel's relatively limited offering.

Management and Analytics

For newcomers, Big Cartel's dashboard is straightforward and easy to assimilate. Shopify offers a robust analytics section, full of insights to help grow your business. These detailed reports and analyses surpass what Big Cartel currently offers.

SEO and Marketing Tools

Shopify takes the crown when it comes to built-in SEO and marketing tools, an area where Big Cartel is noticeably lacking. The ability to create blogs, use advanced SEO techniques, and utilize powerful marketing tools gives Shopify a considerable edge for businesses keen on growth.

Payment Processors and Transaction Fees

Big Cartel offers a narrow selection of payment gateways with no additional transaction fees, an attractive proposition for small business owners. However, Shopify's gamut of over 100 payment options, though charging extra transaction fees, provides flexibility and accommodates a wider customer base.

Customer Support and Community

Both platforms offer support, but Shopify goes the extra mile with 24/7 access through multiple channels including phone and live chat. Big Cartel, mostly operating during business hours with email support, offers a more limited window for assistance.

FAQ Section

Which platform is better for small, independent artists and makers?

Big Cartel may be the better choice for independent artists and makers, focusing on simplicity and ease of use with a free initial option.

Can you scale your business with Big Cartel?

Scaling with Big Cartel is possible but comes with more limitations compared to Shopify, such as product limits and fewer advanced features for big-time growth.

Does Shopify justify its higher price point compared to Big Cartel?

Yes, if you require a platform for growth, diverse payment options, superior customer support, and more robust features, Shopify justifies its price point.

Is it easy to integrate third-party apps with Big Cartel and Shopify?

Shopify excels with an expansive app store allowing integration with a wide array of third-party apps. Big Cartel offers a smaller selection of integrations, adequate for modest needs.

How do these platforms approach SEO and marketing?

Shopify’s comprehensive SEO and marketing tools help maintain your store's visibility and appeal, something Big Cartel offers at a much basic level.

Conclusion

Picking between Big Cartel and Shopify largely depends on your business size, aspirations, and the level of customization you desire. For smaller, creative businesses, Big Cartel's simplicity and affordability are attractive assets. Meanwhile, for scalability, robust functionality, and extensive support, Shopify is the outstanding contender. Ultimately, your decision should align with your long-term business objectives, ensuring that it not only covers your current needs but also fosters future growth.

App Stack